Scottsdale, AZ · Comparing Quotes
Compare Roofing Costs and Warranties in Scottsdale, AZ
Two quotes for the same roof can look wildly different, and the cheaper number isn't always the better deal. Here's what an apples-to-apples comparison actually looks like — scope, materials, and warranty coverage, not just the bottom line. Tip Top Roofing Service is licensed (ROC #355034) and GAF-certified.
- Licensed & Insured - ROC #355034
- GAF-Certified Contractor
- 4.9★ Rating (119 Reviews)
Frequently Asked Questions — Comparing Quotes
What should be included in every roofing quote I compare?
A complete quote should itemize material, full tear-off and disposal, decking inspection and repair allowance, underlayment and flashing, permits and inspections, and both manufacturer and workmanship warranties. If a quote skips several of these, you're not comparing like for like.
What's the difference between a manufacturer warranty and a workmanship warranty?
A manufacturer warranty covers defects in the material itself and comes from the shingle or tile maker. A workmanship warranty covers installation errors and comes from the contractor. You need both — a great material warranty doesn't help if the installation itself was the problem.
Why do quotes for the same job vary so much between contractors?
The biggest driver is usually scope, not price gouging — one quote may include full tear-off and decking repair while another assumes no hidden damage. Always compare what's actually included, not just the bottom-line number.
Does a longer warranty always mean better quality work?
Not necessarily. A long manufacturer warranty reflects the material, not the installer. The workmanship warranty length and the contractor's own track record matter more for judging installation quality.
What should make me question a quote?
A quote with no itemization, no mention of tear-off or decking inspection, or a workmanship warranty shorter than a year or two are all worth asking about before you sign anything.
What a Complete Quote Should Cover
Full Scope
Tear-off, disposal, decking inspection with a clear repair allowance — not just "install new roof."
Materials, Itemized
The exact shingle or tile, underlayment type, and flashing materials — not a vague material category.
Permits & Inspections
Confirmation the contractor handles the entire permitting process, not something you have to chase down.
Both Warranties
Manufacturer warranty on materials, plus a workmanship warranty on the installation itself.
More Roofing Resources
Get a Quote You Can Actually Compare
Fully itemized, with both manufacturer and workmanship warranties spelled out.